The best restaurants near St. Augustine’s Nights of Lights include Columbia Restaurant, Casa Maya, and Michael’s Tasting Room. These restaurants offer convenient locations, delicious food, and a festive atmosphere, making them perfect choices for dining during the holiday season.
Best Places To Eat and Restaurants for Nights of Lights
St. Augustine’s Nights of Lights is a dazzling celebration that transforms the historic city into a glowing wonderland. As you wander through the beautifully lit streets, soaking in the holiday magic, you’ll likely work up an appetite. Luckily, St. Augustine is home to some of the finest dining experiences in Florida, offering a diverse range of culinary delights. Whether you’re seeking a romantic dinner, a family-friendly meal, or a quick bite, this guide will help you discover the best restaurants in St. Augustine and the best places to eat in St. Augustine during the Nights of Lights.
Fine Dining With a View
St. Augustine boasts a number of fine-dining establishments that not only offer exquisite cuisine but also provide stunning views of the city’s historic landmarks and waterfront. These restaurants are perfect for a special night out, allowing you to enjoy the festive atmosphere while savoring some of the best places to eat in St. Augustine.
Columbia Restaurant
Columbia Restaurant is a St. Augustine institution, known for its rich history and delicious Spanish-Cuban cuisine. Located in the heart of the historic district, this restaurant offers a warm and inviting atmosphere, perfect for a special evening during the Nights of Lights. Columbia’s menu features classic dishes like paella “a la Valenciana,” ropa vieja, and their famous 1905 salad, making it one of the best restaurants in St. Augustine for a memorable dining experience.
Casa Maya
Casa Maya offers a unique blend of Mexican and Latin American flavors, with a focus on fresh, locally sourced ingredients. Situated in a charming historic building, the restaurant’s outdoor seating area provides a cozy and intimate setting, ideal for enjoying the holiday lights. The menu includes a variety of seafood dishes, tacos, and vegetarian options, making it one of the best places to eat in St. Augustine for those seeking a flavorful and festive meal.
Michael’s Tasting Room
For a sophisticated dining experience, Michael’s Tasting Room offers a refined menu of contemporary Spanish and Mediterranean cuisine. The restaurant’s elegant interior and outdoor courtyard provide a romantic setting, perfect for a night out during the Nights of Lights. The tasting menu, featuring dishes like pan-seared scallops and beef tenderloin, is a highlight, making it one of the best restaurants in St. Augustine for fine-dining enthusiasts.
Raintree Restaurant
While not within walking distance of the Nights of Lights, the Raintree Restaurant is well worth the short drive. Housed in a restored 19th-century Victorian home, this restaurant offers a charming ambiance and a diverse menu that includes everything from fresh seafood to hearty steaks. The Raintree’s reputation for exceptional service and delicious food makes it one of the best places to eat in St. Augustine for a special occasion.
Romantic Dining Spots
St. Augustine’s historic charm and picturesque setting make it an ideal destination for a romantic evening. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply enjoying a night out with your partner, these romantic restaurants are among the best places to eat in St. Augustine for a memorable dining experience.
Ice Plant Bar
Located in a beautifully restored 1920s-era building, the Ice Plant is a unique dining destination that combines craft cocktails with farm-to-table cuisine. The restaurant’s industrial-chic decor and intimate atmosphere make it a perfect spot for a romantic dinner. The menu features seasonal dishes made with locally sourced ingredients, and the craft cocktail list is one of the best in the city, making it one of the best restaurants in St. Augustine for a cozy and romantic evening.
The Old City House Inn and Restaurant
Nestled in the heart of the historic district, The Old City House Inn and Restaurant offers an elegant dining experience in a beautifully preserved 19th-century building. The restaurant’s intimate dining room and outdoor courtyard provide a romantic setting for couples, while the menu features a variety of Mediterranean-inspired dishes made with fresh, local ingredients. It’s one of the best places to eat in St. Augustine for a romantic night out during the Nights of Lights.
Collage Restaurant
The Collage Restaurant is a top choice for those seeking an intimate and upscale dining experience. The restaurant’s cozy dining room, adorned with local art, creates a warm and inviting atmosphere. The menu, which features a fusion of international flavors, includes dishes like lobster ravioli and rack of lamb, making it one of the best restaurants in St. Augustine for a special date night.
Family-Friendly Eateries
St. Augustine offers a variety of family-friendly restaurants that cater to all ages, making them the best places to eat in St. Augustine for a fun and relaxing meal with your loved ones. These eateries provide a welcoming atmosphere and diverse menus with plenty of options for even the pickiest eaters.
Harry’s Seafood Bar & Grille
Harry’s Seafood Bar & Grille is a popular spot for families visiting St. Augustine. Located in a historic building with a lively courtyard, this restaurant offers a menu full of Cajun- and Creole-inspired dishes. From jambalaya to fried shrimp, there’s something for everyone at Harry’s, making it one of the best restaurants in St. Augustine for a family-friendly meal.
The Florida Cracker Cafe
The Florida Cracker Cafe offers a laid-back dining experience with a menu full of Southern comfort food. Located on St. George Street, this cafe is a great place to stop for a casual lunch or dinner with the family. The menu includes favorites like fried green tomatoes, gator tail, and fish sandwiches, making it one of the best places to eat in St. Augustine for a taste of local flavor.
Barefoot Bill’s Island Grill
Barefoot Bill’s Island Grill is a fun and casual spot that’s perfect for families. The restaurant’s relaxed atmosphere and menu full of burgers, sandwiches and seafood make it a great choice for a quick and satisfying meal. With its convenient location and friendly service, Barefoot Bill’s is one of the best restaurants in St. Augustine for a family-friendly dining experience.
Mojo BBQ Old City
For a taste of authentic Southern barbecue, Mojo BBQ Old City is the place to go. This family-friendly restaurant offers a menu full of smoked meats, hearty sides and homemade sauces. The rustic decor and laid-back vibe make it a great spot for families, and the portions are generous, ensuring everyone leaves satisfied. It’s one of the best places to eat in St. Augustine for a delicious and filling meal with the whole family.
Casual Dining Options
Sometimes, all you want is a casual spot to grab a bite to eat after exploring the city. St. Augustine has plenty of casual dining options that offer delicious food in a relaxed setting, making them the best places to eat in St. Augustine when you’re in the mood for something laid-back.
Pizza Time
Pizza Time is a must-visit for pizza lovers. This casual pizzeria, located on St. George Street, is known for its New York-style slices and fresh ingredients. Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite or enjoying a leisurely meal, Pizza Time offers some of the best pizza in the city, making it one of the best restaurants in St. Augustine for a casual dining experience.
Café Alcazar
Located in the Lightner Museum, Café Alcazar offers a unique dining experience in a historic setting. The cafe is housed in what was once the world’s largest indoor swimming pool and the menu features a variety of fresh and healthy options, including salads, sandwiches and daily specials. The unique ambiance and delicious food make Café Alcazar one of the best places to eat in St. Augustine for a casual yet memorable meal.
The Kookaburra
The Kookaburra is a popular coffee shop and cafe that offers a laid-back atmosphere and a menu full of Australian-inspired treats. Whether you’re stopping in for a coffee and a pastry or grabbing a quick lunch, The Kookaburra is a great place to relax and enjoy a casual meal. Its central location makes it one of the best restaurants in St. Augustine for a quick and tasty bite.
Outdoor Dining With Holiday Views
St. Augustine’s mild climate makes it possible to enjoy outdoor dining year-round, and there’s no better time to take advantage of this than during the Nights of Lights. These restaurants offer outdoor seating with beautiful views of the holiday lights, making them the best places to eat in St. Augustine for a festive dining experience.
The Reef Restaurant
The Reef is a waterfront restaurant that offers stunning views of the Atlantic Ocean. The outdoor seating area provides a serene setting for enjoying fresh seafood and other coastal dishes. The combination of great food and breathtaking views makes The Reef one of the best restaurants in St. Augustine for outdoor dining during the holiday season.
Cap’s On The Water
Cap’s On The Water is another waterfront gem that offers beautiful views and a relaxing atmosphere. The restaurant’s outdoor deck is the perfect spot to enjoy fresh seafood while taking in the scenic views of the Intracoastal Waterway. The laid-back vibe and delicious food make Cap’s On The Water one of the best places to eat in St. Augustine for a casual yet unforgettable dining experience.
Salt Life Food Shack
Salt Life Food Shack is a popular spot for outdoor dining, offering a fun and relaxed atmosphere with a menu full of coastal favorites. The restaurant’s rooftop deck provides great views of the surrounding area, making it a perfect place to enjoy a meal while soaking in the holiday lights. It’s one of the best restaurants in St. Augustine for a festive and enjoyable outdoor dining experience.
Budget-Friendly Eats
You don’t have to spend a fortune to enjoy a great meal in St. Augustine. These budget-friendly restaurants offer delicious food at affordable prices, making them the best places to eat in St. Augustine for those looking to save a little while still enjoying a fantastic dining experience.
Crave Food Truck
Crave Food Truck is a local favorite that offers healthy and flavorful meals on the go. The menu features a variety of bowls, wraps, and smoothies, all made with fresh, locally sourced ingredients. The affordable prices and convenient location make Crave one of the best restaurants in St. Augustine for a quick and budget-friendly meal.
Gypsy Cab Company
Gypsy Cab Company is a St. Augustine institution known for its “urban cuisine,” a fusion of various culinary influences. The restaurant offers a diverse menu at affordable prices, making it a great choice for those looking to enjoy a delicious meal without breaking the bank. The laid-back atmosphere and friendly service make it one of the best places to eat in St. Augustine for a budget-friendly dining experience.
Anastasia Diner
Anastasia Diner is a classic American diner that offers hearty breakfast and lunch options at affordable prices. The menu includes everything from pancakes and omelets to burgers and sandwiches, making it a great spot for a satisfying and budget-friendly meal. Its retro decor and friendly atmosphere make it one of the best restaurants in St. Augustine for a nostalgic dining experience.
FAQs
Yes, there are several family-friendly restaurants in St. Augustine that are perfect for dining during the Nights of Lights, including Harry’s Seafood Bar & Grille, Florida Cracker Cafe, Barefoot Bill’s Island Grill and Mojo BBQ Old City. These eateries offer menus that cater to all ages and provide a welcoming atmosphere for families.
For a romantic dining experience during the Nights of Lights, consider visiting Ice Plant Bar, Old City House Inn and Restaurant, or Collage Restaurant. These spots offer intimate settings, delicious food, and a cozy atmosphere, making them ideal for a special night out with your partner.
Yes, there are several restaurants in St. Augustine that offer outdoor dining with views of the holiday lights. The Reef Restaurant, Cap’s On The Water, and Salt Life Food Shack are all great options for enjoying a meal while taking in the festive sights.
